We’re migrating 75K asset records from a legacy system to CloudSuite ICS 2022. Our data quality analysis revealed issues: 15% missing acquisition dates, 20% have inconsistent depreciation methods, and 10% have invalid location codes.
Our team is split on approach. Some advocate for comprehensive data cleansing in the source system before extraction, while others want to use CloudSuite’s validation tools during import to catch and fix issues on-the-fly.
What’s been your experience with asset data quality during migration? Is it better to invest time in pre-migration cleansing or leverage the target system’s validation capabilities? How do you balance timeline pressure with data integrity requirements?
ICS 2022’s Asset Import utility does provide validation, but it’s basic - field format checks, required field validation, and referential integrity. It won’t catch business logic issues like inconsistent depreciation methods or questionable acquisition dates that are technically valid but don’t make business sense. You need both pre-cleansing for data quality AND import validation for technical compliance.
Let me provide a comprehensive perspective addressing all three aspects of your asset migration challenge.
Data Cleansing Techniques:
The optimal approach is layered cleansing with prioritization:
Tier 1 - Critical Pre-Migration Cleansing (Must Fix Before Import):
- Missing acquisition dates: Research from purchase orders, invoices, or estimate based on asset class and condition
- Invalid location codes: Map to valid CloudSuite location master or create new locations as needed
- Required fields: Asset number, description, asset class, cost center
Tier 2 - Important But Non-Blocking (Fix During Migration Window):
- Inconsistent depreciation methods: Standardize based on asset class and tax requirements
- Missing or incorrect cost centers: Assign defaults based on location or asset type
- Incomplete asset descriptions: Enhance using asset class templates
Tier 3 - Nice-to-Have Improvements (Fix Post-Migration):
- Supplemental asset attributes
- Historical maintenance records
- Asset photos and documentation
For your 75K assets with 45% data issues, focus Tier 1 cleansing on the 15% missing acquisition dates (critical for depreciation) and 10% invalid locations (blocks import). The 20% depreciation method inconsistencies can be standardized programmatically during transformation.
Validation Tool Capabilities:
CloudSuite ICS 2022 Asset Import provides:
Built-in Validation:
- Field format validation (dates, numbers, text length)
- Required field checking
- Referential integrity (location codes, cost centers must exist)
- Duplicate asset number detection
- Basic business rule validation (acquisition date not in future)
Limitations:
- Doesn’t validate business logic complexity (depreciation method appropriate for asset class)
- No cross-field validation (useful life consistent with depreciation method)
- Limited historical data validation
- No automatic correction capabilities
Recommended Validation Strategy:
Pre-Import Validation:
- Run data profiling scripts to identify all data quality issues
- Create exception reports by severity (blocking vs non-blocking)
- Build automated data quality scorecards
- Use SQL queries to validate business rules before extraction
During Import Validation:
- Configure CloudSuite import with strict validation rules
- Enable detailed error logging
- Process in batches (5K assets per batch) to isolate problem records
- Maintain quarantine queue for failed records
Post-Import Validation:
- Run reconciliation reports (count, total acquisition cost, depreciation totals)
- Validate depreciation calculations against legacy system
- Check asset location assignments
- Verify cost center allocations
Asset Data Integrity:
For asset lifecycle data, integrity means:
Financial Integrity:
- Acquisition costs match source system and general ledger
- Accumulated depreciation calculations are accurate
- Net book values reconcile completely
- Depreciation methods comply with accounting standards and tax regulations
Operational Integrity:
- Asset locations are accurate and valid
- Asset relationships (parent-child) are preserved
- Maintenance history is complete
- Warranty and insurance data is current
Compliance Integrity:
- Audit trail from source to target is complete
- Asset capitalization follows company policies
- Tax depreciation methods are correctly applied
- Historical changes are documented
Recommended Implementation Approach:
-
Phase 1 - Assessment (Week 1-2):
- Complete data profiling
- Categorize issues by severity
- Identify root causes of data quality problems
-
Phase 2 - Critical Cleansing (Week 3-6):
- Fix Tier 1 blocking issues in source system
- Document cleansing decisions and rules
- Build transformation scripts for systematic issues
-
Phase 3 - Test Migration (Week 7-8):
- Migrate 5K sample assets representing all issue types
- Validate CloudSuite import error handling
- Refine cleansing and transformation rules
-
Phase 4 - Full Migration (Week 9-10):
- Execute production migration in batches
- Monitor validation errors in real-time
- Address exceptions through established workflows
-
Phase 5 - Post-Migration (Week 11-12):
- Complete reconciliation and validation
- Fix Tier 2 and Tier 3 issues
- Document lessons learned
Timeline vs Data Integrity Balance:
Don’t sacrifice data integrity for timeline. Poor asset data causes ongoing operational problems that far exceed migration delay costs. However, be pragmatic about what must be perfect vs what can be good enough initially.
A 3-month migration with clean data beats a 1-month migration with dirty data that requires 6 months of cleanup afterward. The key is defining clear data quality acceptance criteria upfront and holding firm to those standards while being flexible on less critical attributes.
Consider the downstream impact of data quality issues. Missing acquisition dates affect depreciation calculations, which flow into financial reporting and tax filings. Inconsistent depreciation methods could trigger audit flags. Invalid location codes break asset tracking and physical inventory processes. These aren’t just data issues - they’re business process failures waiting to happen. Clean the data properly before migration.