Thank you all for the excellent questions and insights. Let me address the key points comprehensively:
Audit Trail Components:
We capture extensive audit data in custom table F98951Z: timestamp, AD source group, JDE user ID, roles assigned/removed, automation rule ID, and HR employee record reference. For business justification, we link to the HR system’s job change records. The Python script logs every action with before/after snapshots of user security profiles. We also integrated with our SIEM for real-time alerting on high-privilege role assignments.
Separation of Duties (SOD):
Excellent catch on this. We implemented pre-provisioning SOD checks by integrating with our GRC tool’s conflict matrix. The script queries potential conflicts before executing any role assignment. If conflicts are detected, the user is provisioned with base access only, and an exception workflow routes to security team for manual review. This happens in about 5% of cases.
Terminated Employee Handling:
We built a three-tier deprovisioning model:
- Immediate: Revoke write access within 1 hour of AD status change
- Grace period: Maintain read-only access for 30 days (configurable by department)
- Archive: After 30 days, full deactivation with audit record retention
The grace period logic reads from HR system termination codes - voluntary resignations get 30 days, involuntary terminations get immediate full revocation.
Technical Implementation Details:
# Pseudocode - Key LDAP sync workflow:
1. Connect to AD LDAP server with service account credentials
2. Query AD groups matching pattern 'JDE_*' for membership changes
3. Load mapping table F98950Z (AD group -> JDE roles)
4. For each user change: Check SOD conflicts via GRC API
5. If no conflicts: Call JDE security API to assign/revoke roles
6. Log all actions to F98951Z with timestamp and justification
7. Send notifications to security team for high-risk changes
# Error handling includes retry logic and email alerts
Additional Recommendations:
-
Staging Environment: Linda’s suggestion is excellent. We run the script in ‘preview mode’ first, generating reports of pending changes for security team review before actual execution during business hours.
-
Network Resilience: We implemented connection pooling and exponential backoff for AD queries. The service can tolerate up to 15-minute AD outages without losing sync integrity.
-
Role Drift Prevention: Weekly reconciliation job compares actual JDE security against AD group memberships to catch any manual changes that bypassed automation.
-
Documentation: Maintain detailed mapping documentation linking each AD group to JDE roles with business justification. This is critical for auditor reviews.
The solution has been running for 8 months now with 99.7% uptime. Our SOX audit results improved significantly - zero findings related to user provisioning compared to 12 findings the previous year. The automated audit trail provides auditors with complete visibility into who has access, why they have it, and how it was granted.
For those implementing similar solutions, start with a pilot group (we used our finance department first), validate audit trail completeness before full rollout, and ensure your GRC team is involved from day one to define SOD rules properly.